It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia: Our “The Twelve Days of ‘Sunny’” Winner!

On The Twelfth Day of ‘Sunny,’ The Gang from Paddy’s gave to me…

…twelve widowed Dennis-es

…eleven sleepless suburban nights

…ten crates of live chickens

…nine ninjas fighting

…eight hits of bath salts

…seven Thunder Gun Express sequels…

…six stolen Omnibots

…FIIIIIIIIIVE INCH WOUND ON CRICKET’S NECK!

Four times Charlie lost it

…three huffs of spray paint

…two months community service…

…and Dee Reynolds in a pear tree!

always sunny s03e09
FX

So now that we’ve reached the end of our 12-season rundown on the best episodes from each season with The Gang from Paddy’s Pub–Charlie (Charlie Day), Mac (Rob McElhenney), Dee (Kaitlin Olson), Frank (Danny DeVito), and Dennis (Glenn Howerton), it’s time to crown “The Best of the Best” from FX/FXX‘s It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia – and dump a little coal in your stockings with the worst It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia  episode of the first 12 seasons (spoiler: it’s probably holding the crown next year, too).

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia s04e13 ‘The Nightman Cometh’: With the gang’s help, Charlie stages a rock opera based on his song “Nightman.” Writer: Charlie Day & Glenn Howerton & Rob McElhenney / Director: Matt Shakman

Do I really need to explain why this episode would rise above eleven other worthy contenders? The episode is achieving Rocky Horror Picture Show status – in fact, you probably either hummed or sang the song to yourself at least once by the time you got to this point in the article.

FXX

Believe it or not, ‘The Nightman Cometh’ reached its tenth anniversary on November 20th – so to celebrate both that occasion and the honor of being at the top of our list, here’s a look back to when Day, Howerton, McElhenney, Olson, DeVito, episode director Matt Shakman, and others sat down to discuss how the episode came to be, what it was like performing live, and their thoughts on the episode’s enducance:

● On the risk of doing a musical episode that comedically blurs the line between “a boy’s coming of age story” and story about pedophilia and rape and how the show handled it seriously:

“Any time we deal with that kind of subject matter, I like to think it’s coming from a more intelligent place. A rape joke is not remotely a funny thing; a man writing a musical that he thinks is about self-empowerment, and not realizing that all his lyrics sound like they’re about a child being molested, is a funny thing. The joke is coming from confusion and misunderstanding, which are classic tropes of all comedy.” – Day

“We look back at some of our past shows and wonder if we’d still be able to do that. I hope the answer is yes, because if you’re paying attention, we’re pretty good people with fairly liberal views on things. We’re making a social commentary.” – Olson

FXX

● Thanfully, the cast had enough collective musical experience to make the episode’s creative process a little easier. Well, almost everyone had musical experience…

“I’m not musically inclined in any way, shape, or form. But Charlie is an incredible musician, so he and [composer] Cormac Bluestone wrote the majority of the music. In terms of lyrics, we all had a hand in them. But Charlie definitely took the lead.” – McElhenney

FXX

● On working with piano player Gladys (Mae LaBorde), who was constantly confused over what exactly she was playing piano for – and represented a “first” for Shakman:

“They would say “action” and she was just, like, talking. She would tell us that we’re all wonderful, beautiful people and she was happy to be there. Which was really charming but also very funny, because she had lines and she wasn’t saying them.” – Day

“When you get to be as old as she was, you can do whatever you want… Just getting the lines out was very difficult. I remember being backstage with her, talking about Calvin Coolidge, she just went on for so long. It might’ve been the longest scene I’ve ever shot for Sunny.” – Shakman

FX/FXX

● Performing ‘The Nightman Cometh’ on the road for a mini-tour of six cities (New York, L.A., San Francisco, Seattle, Boston, and Philadelphia) gaveDeVito an opportunity to perform where his career first started; for Olson, the shows gave her and the cast a better understanding of how strong and loyal their fanbase was:

“We played the Beacon Theatre in New York, where I once saw Bob Marley play in the early ’70s. I lived on 89th Street when I was starting out, so this was my home turf. I invited everybody I could think of to come. Some of my friends came backstage; they were like deer in headlights. They had no idea what was going on.” – DeVito

“It really gave us our first insight into just how many fans we had. Because we were basically being told: Nobody’s watching the show but FX likes it, so that’s why you’re still on the air. We weren’t having huge ratings, but we had a big fan base. And those people traveled and packed those theaters.” – Olson

FXX

● So why has ‘The Nightman Cometh’ not only endured but grown in popularity over the past ten years? For McElhenney, it was something different that kept to the heart and spirit of the series while also showing a little heart:

“Ultimately, in a show that is so inherently profane—and the characters are so difficult and hard to watch at times—the ending of that particular episode was very sweet. You find out that Charlie’s doing the whole thing because he’s in love with somebody and he’s asking her to marry him. Of course, the Sunny version of that is that the relationship is exceptionally unhealthy and that she says no, but I think his motivation comes from a really sweet place. So that buys us a lot in the episode. Also, like it or hate it, we’ve always strived to do something that nobody else is doing, and I think some people respond to that. It just feels very specific to us and to the show.” – McElhenney

As for our “big lump of coal” – the worst It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia episode of all time?

always sunny 12days winner

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia s07e05 ‘Frank’s Brother’: The Gang is shocked to meet Frank’s long-lost brother Gino: he unexpectedly arrives at Paddy’s Pub, and exposes a wealth of family secrets. Writer: David Hornsby / Director: Matt Shakman

Yes, the same person who directed our best episode also directed our worst. Hey, it happens. But to be clear? This isn’t one of those “gets better with age” examples or “so bad it’s good” kind – it’s just stinks on all levels. Jon Polito‘s pulled together an impressive body of film and television work over the years – but as Frank’s brother Gino? Not so good – same thing with how Frank is represented in the episode. From a backstory that doesn’t gel with what we know from previous episodes to the jokes to the overall pacing, everything seems off – like an episode put together by fans who think they can do a better It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia episode.

About Ray Flook

Proudly serving as TV Editor, Ray started with Bleeding Cool in 2013 as a contributing writer/photographer before being brought aboard as staff in 2017. Counting John Cusack as his pop culture "spirit animal," his "word fu" stays strong as he continues trying really hard to be the sheppard...

twitter   facebook square   instagram   envelope