Brandon Graham is a cartoonist whose work you may be familiar with from the likes of writing a Prophet and Prophet: Earth War reboot, his TokyoPop series King City, and Elevator from Meathaus from back in the day, his more recent anthology from Image, Island, Multiple Warheads and 8House, as well as contributions to Shutter, The Wicked + The Divine and Transmetropolitan. But he started drawing pornographic comics, and it is fair to say that this aesthetic still informs much of his work.
He was one of the principal figures behind criticism of Brian Wood for his treatment of women a few years ago. In recent years he has also picked up a degree of criticism regarding how he both portrays and treats women, with stories going back to his college days. However, he has recently worked with a number of prominent women comics creators including Emma Rios, Kelly Sue DeConnick and Marian Churchland and his Island and 8House projects were seen by some as a way to encourage and promote minority voices in comics.
In April, cartoonist Carta Monir posted a thread regarding Brandon, in which she solicited negative stories about him.
This has been a long time coming, and an open secret among comics women. I'm speaking out bc I don't think he has any power over my career. Please reach out if you have had negative experiences with him and I will publicize them anonymously.
— Carta Monir (@CartaMonir) April 9, 2018
Hearing from ppl, here's a representative one:
"The dude has been an absolute creep for YEARS … he only got interested in my partners work after she transitioned and tried to be waaaaay too familiar with her without her consent in really public spaces. He’s gross af."
— Carta Monir (@CartaMonir) April 9, 2018
I've been hearing from a fair number of ppl, but a lot of them are nervous that their experiences will expose them to harassment. Here, however, is one I have permission to share: pic.twitter.com/htuMqGj8RU
— Carta Monir (@CartaMonir) April 10, 2018
Brandon was denying, equivocating, and replying on Twitter. Those responses have now been deleted, but this was screencapped.
Ok, this is a “real” accusation. And, for the record, the way u and your ppl have responded is EXACTLY why people have been afraid to come forward. pic.twitter.com/DgP1MJtBXY
— Carta Monir @ CAKE 512b-ish (@CartaMonir) April 11, 2018
As the stories began to grow, Nick Hanover ran an editorial on Loser City called On Brandon Graham, Weaponized Loyalty and Recognizing Abuse Tactics which detailed issues that people had with Graham and how some of his previous supporters were changing their minds about the man:
Comics seems particularly vulnerable to predators like Graham because not only are there far fewer opportunities than hopeful pros, the opportunities that are available are frequently acquired through networking. Someone like Graham legitimately was able to give opportunities to people and establish himself as a key ally to trans creators in particular– indeed he was one of the few people consistently getting trans creators published, making it all that much easier for him to convince potential targets he was necessary for their careers and to also convince people that any action against him would cause the network he had built for them to crumble.
As criticism was mounting, Graham deleted his Twitter account again. Yesterday he posted to Tumblr what he refers to as his “diss track”, in which he answers critics, insults them, and doubles humblebrag down on his personal life too.
(UPDATE: The original has now been removed and replaced. It is still available on Google cache. Here’s what was the first page)
It has now been replaced by the following image entitled ‘bullies’.
And the floodgates opened…
boldest comics move of 2018 is brandon graham releasing a “diss track” comic that basically disses himself into oblivion
— Charlie Chu (@CharlieChu) June 4, 2018
Brandon Graham, who just uploaded a tantrum in comic format lecturing the people he's made angry/uncomfortable how to best deal with the problems he creates, spent literal years telling everyone he could I was transphobic.
He continued to do so after being repeatedly corrected.
— Iron Spike (@Iron_Spike) June 4, 2018
anyway, it was a pleasant feeling knowing I was reading my very last Brandon Graham comic ever.
— Christopher Sebela (@xtop) June 4, 2018
Jesus Christ, Brandon Graham is GARBAGE
— Jennifer de Guzman in a Coma (@Jennifer_deG) June 4, 2018
I stand with the women who spoke out about Brandon Graham. He's an abusive scumbag and his work deserves the recycling bin.
— Julia Kaye! (@upandoutcomic) June 4, 2018
Listen. I'll grant that maybe Brandon Graham doesn't know how he fucked up. But you know what a real ally does when *everyone in the community he wronged* is telling them they fucked up? They'd go "oh, shit. I am so sorry. I will amend my behavior and own my mistakes."
— Magdalene Visaggio (@MagsVisaggs) June 4, 2018
I got a small story about Brandon Graham that's been bugging me for ages and really should've been when I cut the dude out of my life. Like, if y'all aren't going to listen to the women who've been talking about this I dunno what to tell you, but maybe this'll help.
— @firstname.lastname@example.org (@itsnero) June 4, 2018
Honestly this parody of my work is the most interesting thing Brandon has drawn in years pic.twitter.com/NROyuGn1wO
— Carta Monir (@CartaMonir) June 4, 2018
This attention has given the chance for some to spread attention to the work of those affected. But also, inevitably, will produce more Tumblr posts. Brandon told me:
I made that comic after one of the roughest weeks of my life, feeling really gaslit about allegations against me. While no one would even tell me what I was actually being accused of or give me any hope of improving the situation.
I feel like a big part of my work and career has been me speaking honestly about what was going on in my head, for good or ill. So having something this big hanging over me while feeling like I was unable to speak on it or even defend my own experience was beyond frustrating.
I should be clear, that the comic was not intended to win anyone over– I’m miles beyond any interest in playing politics or being part of any scene that has more interest in my failure than success — it was meant as a “f-ck you” to people who threw around my name- along with some clarity for my own sake.