The Crow Memento Mori #1 Review: Missing Every Point Going

Posted by March 30, 2018 Comment

The Crow: Memento Mori #1
2.5 Reviewer
0 Users (0 votes)
BC Rating
Summary
Writers: Roberto Recchioni and Matteo Scalera, Artists: Werther Dell'Edera and Matteo Scalera, Color Artists: Giovanni Niro and Moreno Diniso, Letters: Giovanni Marinovich, Special Thanks to Tommaso Destefanis for helping with the text Cover by: Werther Dell'Edera and Giovanni Niro, Variant Covers by: Davide Furno; Matteo Scalera and Moreno Diniso; Roberto Recchioni; Drew Moss, Editors: Marco Schiavone and Daniel de Filippis, Editor for IDW: David Hedgecock, Production: Gilberto Lazcano, Publisher: Greg Goldstein, Publishing Company: IDW Publishing, Release Date: Out Now, Price: $3.99

A Catholic alter boy, his girlfriend, and dozens of others are killed in a terrorist attack in Rome, Italy. That alter boy, David Amadio, didn’t stay dead though. He was resurrected as the Crow to take vengeance on those who committed the atrocity.

The Crow: Memento Mori #1 cover by Werther Dell'Edera and Giovanni Niro
The Crow: Memento Mori #1 cover by Werther Dell’Edera and Giovanni Niro

In high school, I was a huge fan of James O’Barr’s the Crow. I loved the graphic novel, and I loved the Brandon Lee-led film. I am aware that plenty of sequels to both the graphic novel and the film, and I am aware of the flaws in both. However, I’m still fond of both, and this is the first new series to be released in the Crow franchise since I’ve worked for BC.

Unfortunately, this one is shockingly bad independent of my feelings of the original tale. In fact, this comic is the kind of thing that people probably think O’Barr’s Crow is.

The edginess dripping off Memento Mori #1. The beginning is a swarm of violent Bible verses followed by the protagonist monologuing to the audience about how “Thou shall not kill” is the Sixth Commandment.

David is surprisingly smug for a Crow, as he constantly brags about being an agent of God.

He catches up to the terrorists in the first issue. Nuance flies out the window as he brutally murders the perpetrators, one of which is a terrified 17-year-old boy. I’m not asking for a full opus on the complex motivations behind terrorism, but it would be nice to not treat the death of a minor like a money shot.

Here, I do have to make a brief comparison to O’Barr’s classic. The original Crow graphic novel at least showed the slightest bit of sympathy for the targets of Eric’s vengeance. He even sat with a man as he bled out. The comic was contemplative, arguably to a fault.

The dialogue leaves a lot to ask for, with my favorite bad line being, “Jesus rose from the dead in three days. It took me only one… Everything’s faster these days, don’t you know?”

The funny kicker is that the B-story directly contradicts the main story’s Christian-centric narrative with a bit of paganism.

The Crow: Memento Mori #1 art by Werther Dell Edera and Giovanni Niro
The Crow: Memento Mori #1 art by Werther Dell Edera and Giovanni Niro

Werther Dell’Edera’s artwork is gritty, gory, and plays with shading well. It holds together well throughout the comic and is supported well by Giovanni Niro’s color art. Matteo Scalera’s work in the backup story looks great too.

The Crow: Memento Mori #1 shows a ponderous franchise reduced to simple revenge fantasy. While the original tale and earlier sequels and adaptations were not perfect, most give the reader something more than brutal murder with a grinning protagonist. While the art and the backup story are solid enough, the main narrative leaves a vile taste in the mouth. Give this one a wide berth.

What people say... Leave your rating
Sort by:

Be the first to leave a review.

User Avatar
Verified
{{{ review.rating_title }}}
{{{review.rating_comment | nl2br}}}

Show more
{{ pageNumber+1 }}

Leave your rating

(Last Updated March 30, 2018 3:53 pm )

About Joshua Davison

Josh is a longtime super hero comic fan and an aspiring comic book and fiction writer himself. He also trades in videogames, Star Wars, and Magic: The Gathering, and he is also a budding film buff. He's always been a huge nerd, and he hopes to contribute something of worth to the wider geek culture conversation. He is also happy to announce that he is the new Reviews Editor for Bleeding Cool. Follow on Twitter @joshdavisonbolt.

View All Posts


Send this to a friend