The survivors are on their way to save Ruckus from “Officer Friendly.” Gabe, Carla, Forest, and Sparky are assembled to infiltrate the sheriff’s office where Ruckus is held. Forest is reluctant, but the other three are determined.
After deliberation and planning, the team goes in.
I’ve not played the tabletop game the Dead of Winter comic is based upon. I’m generally not too interested in tabletop board games; Magic: The Gathering, comics, and the occasional videogame purchase already take up enough the money I should be saving as well as the time I should be using to write.
I don’t see why that should be relevant to my judgement of this comic, but I like to be transparent with my prior interactions with a property.
In any case, I’ve more or less been affiliated with this property before in a different way. It’s called The Walking Dead. There’s more humor focus on quirky humor and a vastly different aesthetic style with Dead of Winter for sure, but it’s comics is pretty much The Walking Dead.
That feeling of being here before is a problem on its own, but, if it did something unique with its similarities, it wouldn’t be as big a problem. However, Dead of Winter is almost aggressively conventional.
Its characters are vague archetypes. Its humor is painfully ill-timed and—well, not particularly funny. Its tone is non-existent with characters on the verge of death followed by a joke about Forest being useless.
And the art is barebones. Nothing is especially well-detailed; the cutesy pseudo-Scott Pilgrim style does not fit with whatever the narrative tone is trying to accomplish. The coloring is aptly greyed out, but that’s assuming this is supposed to be a gritty survival story. It may not be; this may be intended as a Walking Dead satire. If so, it doesn’t accomplish that.
I don’t feel great eviscerating a comic like this, but, frankly, it doesn’t work on almost any level. The finale to it, without spoiling anything, is a rather manipulative play on readers’ emotions, and it feels very hollow. The tone is so all over the place that I’m not sure what the intent of the comic was. Steer clear of this one. Even if you are a fan of the tabletop game, it’s still not worth a read.
Be the first to leave a review.
- Iceman #1 Review: A Very Welcome Return - September 12, 2018
- House of Whispers #1 Review: Sandman Universe Struggling to Create Engagement - September 12, 2018
- Infinity Wars #3 Review: What if Captain America but Also Doctor Strange? - September 12, 2018
- Weapon X #23 Review: Deadpool is a Comic-Killer - September 11, 2018
- Nightwing #48 Review: The Motor Cycle Race of the Cosmos - September 11, 2018