“Twilight For Boys” – The New Scott Pilgrim Review Meme

Visual from rottentomatoes.

The Twilight comparison isn’t one I’m using just to tie in to the flavor of the month(year?); it’s a pretty apt assessment. Twilight succeeded because it put a relatable character in a miraculous situation and gave them a love interest that exceeded their possible expectations. It was aspirational. Scott Pilgrim is the same.

Sarcastic Gamer

It’s Twilight for boys. It’s male adolescent sexual angst as “an epic of epic epicness,” as the poster tagline informs us… and as the movie matches in attitude and action. It’s the indulgence of everything a not-quite-adult, no-longer-a-kid manchild could want from women, in a package designed to appeal to not-quite-adult, no-longer-a-kid manchildren who would happily see their lives in the metaphors of the comic books, sitcoms, and videogames they were weaned on.

Flick Filosopher

In many ways, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World is the equivalent of the Twilight Saga for boys. It is deeply rooted in pubescent romantic fantasy, albeit this time from the male’s point of view. It is foolish and shallow about the ways of relationships, pandering to the basest instincts of the target audience.

Huffington Post

Make no mistake about it, there is definitely a formula at work here. I’ve heard it said that Scott Pilgrim is Twilight for teenage guys, with a few appropriate swaps put in place.

Salon

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World is the equivalent of the Twilight Saga for gamers

Destructoid

SCOTT PILGRIM = TWILIGHT for boys

AsimovLives@AintItCool

Major thanks to Little Bleeder Beto_Machado of the Bleeding Cool Forums

It's Comic Con week! Comics, Film, TV, and much more... Check out complete coverage on the Bleeding Cool San Diego Comic Con Hub.