SDCC ’15: Industry Editors Provide An Insider View And Advice On Editing

By Michele Brittany, West Coast Correspondent

Aspen Comics’ Editor-in-Chief and VP Vince Hernandez moderated the panel Comic Industry Editorial Panel – 2015 and gathered together several editors together for an hour’s opportunity where the audience could ask questions about the editorial process. Making up the panel of experts included Chris Ryall, IDW’s Editor-in-Chief; Barbara Kesel, Consultant and formerly with DC Comics; Matt Hawkins, Top Cow Productions’ Publisher; Shannon Eric Denton, Lions Forge Editor-in-Chief; and David Wohl, writer and former editor at Radical Comics.

MBrittany_Editorial_1The first attendee asked for tips about putting together an anthology. Kesel responded that it was important to make sure that everyone involved in the project understand the mission and focus of the book, so that everyone worked as a cohesive group, not disjointed and independently of each other and the editor’s goals for the project.

A question that often comes up is whether a writer should include art when they are submitting a pitch. Per Ryall, editors are very busy so he advised the more a writer can do up front helps the prospective editor. Hawkins said that less is more and when he reads a pitch, he is looking for a reason to stop. All the panelists confirmed to make sure that the pitch is acceptable and appropriate for the publisher. The last thing a person can overlook is to not do their homework about the publisher. Kesel added that there are grants available to writers and there is always self-publishing avenues. Ryall stated that more often than not, if editors need new projects, more often editors will be the ones reaching out to talent.

MBrittany_Editorial_2Hernandez reminded attendees that first impressions are important so put forth the best impression possible. He advised to take time and get the project done right; do not rush it just to try to make an unrealistic deadline that will negatively impact your project’s quality. Ryall agreed and added that a face-to-face meeting is not the end all, be all. Hawkins was blunt: do not be an ass.

A clarifying question regarding pitch came up: did the pitch have to be fully developed? Kesel said no, it just needs to be high quality but not dense. She advised to have a strong nugget in your pitch. Denton added that if, in your creative process you need to develop a script to create your pitch, that’s fine, but be aware that if your pitch is accepted, then your script will change. Hernandez said to work to your strengths and know that you will have collaboration once you are picked up. Hawkins said to be concise and keep it brief. Wohl added to show the editor why your project is unique, and make sure you have a clean cover letter.

MBrittany_Editorial_3The editors are busy and any way that writers and artists can make their jobs easier is more apt to find work. One way is to know what you are capable of and what kind of deadlines you can keep, according to Ryall. Have a strong individual voice added Kesel. Denton agreed and reiterated to work with your editor, not make it harder on them. Kesel added that the editor is not your adversary; so don’t go into a project with that attitude.

Trends. Do comic book editors pick projects that are part of a trend? Kesel said that she is cognizant of trends, but it doesn’t drive her choices. Hawkins said that he would prefer to be ahead of trends. Ryall commented that he thinks that comics can more easily respond to what fans want than other mediums in popular culture.

MBrittany_Editorial_4The last question came from an illustrator in the audience who asked if she needed to include dialogue on her pages even though she knows that her strength is her artistic abilities. Hawkins recommended stripping the dialogue and concentrating on the art. Kesel agreed: state your idea in the cover letter but focus on the art.

Event photos were taken by Michele Brittany.

Michele Brittany is an independent popular culture scholar and semi-professional photographer and editor of James Bond and Popular Culture: Essays on the Influence of the Fictional Superspy (McFarland & Company) as well as the forthcoming book Essays on Space Horror in Films, 1950s – 2000s. Read her reviews and analysis on the spy/espionage and space horror genres via her blogs at Spyfi & Superspies and Space Horror Films. Follow Michele on Twitter: @mcbrittany2014.