Now now, boys - nothing wrong with either of those two ladies.
<- This guy's pretty happy about this news. I was going to see this flick regardless, but now I'm excited about it.
Okay looks wise and if we don't count that Angelina is getting older, either lady would be great. But I think Eva is best for the part because she's so good at being pissed off. I hate to recommend that Camelot Teenaged King Arthur show to anyone because overall it's a pretty crappy show, but Eva Green really impressed me on that show with how intensely, frighteningly pissed off she could be. So between her looks and her ability to portray super anger better than about anyone I think she's perfect for the part. She'd be perfect for the Barroness, too.
Well, at least the rest of the cast is stunning and on point. Looking forward this (finally).
I should add on to this that I don't think very much of Jolie either so I wasn't saying Jolie is my preferred choice over Green. I'll take it on faith that you guys know what you're talking about because all I really know Green from is Casino Royale.