
Originally Posted by
hammerstein
I hope we're wrong...but I also really wanted Del Toro for the Hobbit (as a single non do-you-want-fries-with-your-franchise? movie)
His design and directorial aesthetic would have been the perfect match, but also because it would connect but differentiate The Hobbit from LOTR more distinctly.
Again, i really want to be wrong...but Kong was pretty lumpy and unsatisfying.
It would take a master editor and writer to weave a great narrative out of the Hobbit and Tolkien's other works such as The Silmarillion
(which is completely unlike the Hobbit - ie HEAVILY steeped in language and lore)