Kyle Baker On Miley Cyrus, Charlie Chaplin And The Twerk Heard Round The World

Let me start by saying that Kyle Baker posted this on his blog and mentions wanting the page hits… so please go here for his entire post and make Mr. Baker happy.

MileyAs for what he wrote:

I’m a Miley fan from way back. I remember watching “Hanna Montana” on TV with my kids, and laughing aloud at the skills of an incredibly gifted comic actress. I think she and Raven Simone are the funniest of the Disney pack.

Last night, humanity lost their collective minds at what they consider to be the latest proof of the End Of Days; Miley’s twerk. Judging from the internet messages friends and relatives are sending me, the importance of the Twerk Heard Round The World rivals, no, surpasses the severity of the Fukushima meltdown which has the world’s military forces currently united to avert the end of life as we know it. To demonstrate I have my priorities in order, I shall now elaborate on the subject of the controversial Cyrus Twerk, mainly because I want the page hits.

The dance number Miley performed at the VMAs was a reprise of her performance in the nominated music video WE CAN’T STOP The refrain of the song is “WE CAN DO WHAT WE WANT TO.” The video is clearly intended as comedy. Miley Cyrus is a very successful and hilarious COMIC. The video features dancing bear costumes, Miley making out with a mannequin, a guy eating money in a sandwich, and all sorts of funny stuff like that. In the video scene where Miley twerks, she is being mocked by a group of well-endowed black women who shake their heads derisively. The casting of this shot highlights the fact that Miley lacks the key piece of anatomical equipment necessary for an effective twerk. It also points out that Miley is not Black, and that she looks ridiculous trying to act like a Black girl, with her silly-looking hip-hop grill and ghetto gestures. She’s DELIBERATELY being crazy and silly in the video, she’s famous for being FUNNY! The video illustrates the sentiment, “I CAN DO WHAT I WANT TO.”

I suspect that it is the message, not the Twerk, that people are so terrified of. I recently watched a much-maligned work of another great comedian, Charlie Chaplin’s film, “Monsieur Verdoux”. I was spellbound by this film, and consider it to be one of Chaplin’s best.

Bear with me, I’ll get back to Miley’s buttocks soon enough.

Watching “Monsieur Verdoux”, and then reading about the how the critics and public attacked this film and Chaplin when it was released, a thought occurred to me; Many artists have a similar creative arc. Early success followed by public vilification. It also seems to me that I usually prefer the latter-day work to the more popular early work of these artists.

Artists go through phases. At the beginning of our creative career, we need public approval. We need to get that first job, a foot in the door, a career launch. Popularity is a priority. Chaplin’s “Little Tramp” films were a celebration of the working-class people who bought movie tickets. The films were designed to entertain an audience that was struggling with economic collapse and in desperate need of reassurance and laughter. Chaplin’s Tramp was a poor working stiff at the mercy of evil bankers, landlords, and supervisors. He always outsmarted the villains and triumphed, which warmed the hearts of the downtrodden audiences facing similar struggles in real life. Miley’s “Hanna Montana” was a formulaic Disney product, full of everything Disney does best; crowd-pleasing popular entertainment designed for the broadest audience possible in order to collect millions of dollars in revenue. (Walt Disney’s Mickey Mouse was actually patterned after Chaplin’s Tramp, which set the template for all Disney product which followed.)

This brings us to the next phase of an artist’s development…

The rest of Baker’s response is available on his website. It’s quite entertaining and well written… Go read the rest.



10 Page Preview Of Paul Jenkins And Andy Clarke’s Replica #1, Out This Wednesday From After Shock Comics


Star Wars Rebels Renewed For A Third Season

2000AD And Valiant Comics Advance Further Into Europe

The Bleeding Cool Top 100 Power List 2015 – 64 To 62

'Mission: Impossible - Rogue Nation' world premiere at the Vienna State Opera (Wiener Staatsoper)

Featuring: Christopher McQuarrie
Where: Vienna, Austria
When: 23 Jul 2015
Credit: Toppress/


Christopher McQuarrie Accepts Mission: Impossible 6


Death Sentence: London No.6 From Titan Comics Preview


J.J. Abrams Says Star Wars: The Force Awakens Is Done; Doesn’t Want To Ruin Movie With Spoilers


Kieron Gillen Talks To The People Of London Via Underground Staff With Time On Their Hands

"Stronger Together" -- When Kara's (Melissa Benoist) attempts to help National City don't go according to plan, she must put aside the doubts that she -- and the city's media -- has about her abilities in order to capture an escapee from the Kryptonian prison, Fort Rozz, when SUPERGIRL moves to its regular time period, Monday, Nov. 2 (8:00-9:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network. Photo: Cliff Lipson/CBS ©2015 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Supergirl Gets An Additional Seven Episode Order

21 Cyber-Monday Comic Book Deals – Buy One Get Two, Buy One Get Three, Buy Loot Crate Get Socks