What Exactly Did Robert Venditti Say About Plans To Kill Off John Stewart?

jsA month ago, Bleeding Cool broke the story that Joshua Hale Fialkov had walked off his Green Lantern books in protest in being told to kill off DC’s most prominent black character, John Stewart.

Our version of events was later backed up by Comic Book Resources and Comics Beat, but online DC seems to throw water over it, with Alex Segura’s tweet;


John Stewart co-creator Neal Adams was quoted as saying;

I had Jim Lee called and I had Dan Didio called. Ok. Because I can do that. They said “No that’s bullshit. That’s total bullshit.” Now that could still be a lie. You know. It could happen.

Bleeding Cool had by then run a piece detailing DC’s flip-flop on the issue… but had DC even planned to kill John Stewart or was it some media fueled flight of fancy?

Now CBR have interviewed Robert Venditti about the situation, and while he backs up his previous statement that;


By saying;

We were brought onto the book and we had a very clear idea of what we wanted to do with John that never involved killing him. Nobody ever asked us to kill him and really I thought for a long time whether I should even respond to [the rumors and speculation online] because I don’t really talk about my stories much in that sense…

Since we were brought onboard before the news of John Stewart being killed off was even out there and we never had any plans to kill him, it should seem obvious that our decision to not kill him wasn’t based on any sort of fan reaction because the decision was made before the fans knew there was something to react to.

Note some specific language choices in the second quoted paragraph there. “News” now, not “rumours” and “the decision was made” – so there was a specific decision being made about whether John Stewart would live or die?

Maybe that reading-between-the-lines is the closest we’ll ever get…

The Bleeding Cool Top 100 Power List 2015 – 61 To 59


Hamilton And The Force Awakens Collide And Other Tales Of The Star Wars


CBLDF Offers Up Some Goodies For #GivingTuesday


Brian K. Vaughan Launches New Digital Comics With Marcos Martin / Muntsa Vincente


Cover Stories – Mary Jane, Klaus And Return To A New Hope

Is Daisy Willing To Forgive Grant For Being Part Of HYDRA?

Walking Dead Prologue Drops Name Comic Fans Have Been Waiting For

The Cast Of Flash / Arrow Talk Tonight’s Crossover

Bring on the Little Terrors

Tom Hiddleston Is Hank Williams In New Trailer For I Saw The Light