No, This Is Not A Continuity Flub In Before Watchmen: Minutemen

We’d mentioned how Seymour couldn’t have been writing for the New Frontiersman in 1975. But that was just a marketing bit of bumf.

But the first issue of Before Watchmen: Minutemen goes out of its way to line itself up to the future. Hollis Mason moving into the aprtment he will one day die in, including time spent with the statue that will one day become his murder weapon. We see the building being built that will one day be Ozymandias’ tower. And we get an extract of Hollis Mason trying to write the end of his book Under The Hood.

Which causes a problem. For some. Specifically this bit.

Naming Eduardo Blake as a costume adventurer of the Minutemen. And that one of the main points of the initial plot of Watchmen is that no one knows Eduardo Blake is the Comedian.

Execept… and here’s what some people aren’t getting. We read the initial white box captions as part of what Hollis is planning to write for the end of his book.

But the second time they appear, it’s meant to be internal narrative, Hollis telling his story to us – but not the story that he wrote in his book. Indeed there are a number of discrepencies between what he is saying here and what is published and seen in Watchmen. So naming Edward Blake as the Comedian – to us – is fine.

Using the same caption system for both is unnecessarily confusing. It’s a mistake. It’s not a Moore mistake, he is very deliberate over captioning and the differential of such – when he makes them confusing or similar, such as in Neonomicon, it’s there to deliberately blur the lines of reality. But in Watchmen, the captions are often artifacts – Rorschach’s diary or lettering from The Black Freighter – or the blue and white bordered narrative of Dr Manhattan.

Here we get two different narratives treated in the same way, so you can forgive people’s confusion.

Sloppy, possibly. Slip, no.

LegenderryVampi01-Cov-K-ExcluBoxDread-Castro

Vampirella Climbs Into The Box Of Dread

Old-Wounds-Page-02

A New Look At Old Wounds

IMG_8645

The Full Content Of January’s ‘Rewind’ Loot Crate Reviewed

A Comic Show – Endgame For Batman & The Avengers!

Og_2

Sideshow Unveils Court Of The Dead Digital Comic

Phat Con 5

Phat Con Expands In Its Return To SoCal, Proves Popular

GOTHMID_Cv3_ds_54c2d98a3d46e2.74603174

Preview Of Gotham By Midnight #3 By Fawkes And Templesmith

hidden-banner

Heart-Wrenching Realities In Hidden: A Child’s Story Of The Holocaust

Alex Simmons

Impressions From The Black Comic Book Festival At the Schomburg Center

BC_12

From Strip to Script – A Jack Kirby Fight Scene